Featured post

Flim Blog: Extra Credit

Dear ENG 270 Students:

Use this class blog  to complete the extra assignments for the films. You should write a 500 word critical review of a key scene from one of the films.  In your review you will want to explain how the scene you have chosen makes a statement about American identity.

What can you argue about identity and this scene? You should also relate your scene to a key term, convention, or theme that we have explored this semester.

Only one entry per student per film is allowed. You may write about all four films for a total of 100 points (25pts each). This assignment is worth up to 3% of your final grade in the course.

To get started, see your TA for access to authoring the blog.

You may add images or video clips to your posts. Please make sure you tag your post in the categories section by selecting your TA’s name.

Featured post

Welcome to ENG 270 American Identities Blog

How have artists expressed what it has meant to be an American at key moments in our national cultural history? This class will use fiction (novels, short stories, graphic novels, science fiction) and visual culture (film clips, television, and American photography) to introduce some of the most persistent themes and issues that have been articulated in postmodern and contemporary American culture and letters.  Some of the themes we will track this semester include: desire, simulation, alienation, existentialism, authenticity, and reinvention.

The Matrix

The Matrix contains many ideas about our interaction with identity.  In particular the scene where Cipher is bargaining with Agent Smith brings up many ideas about American identity.  Cipher bargains with the Agents to get himself reinstated into the Matrix.  He does not want to live in reality and greatly prefers the ignorance of being in the Matrix.  He has become disillusioned in the literal sense.  Cipher’s attitude can be seen as representative of part of the American identity.  Many Americans live in ignorance in today’s society.  In the beginning our country was founded on the idea of the informed citizenry, however the reality has become something very different.  Many Americans don’t bother with informing themselves about politics, whether it is in their town, in their country, or on the world stage.  Cipher represents these feelings in the American citizenry.  He is living in a world where practically all of humanity is enslaved by machines.  The Earth has been pretty much destroyed, the sun cannot penetrate the atmosphere, thunder storms ravage the landscape, and it is completely devoid of life.  Instead of dealing with these issues and fighting for his people he wishes to go back to the hallowed ignorant bliss he lived in while in the Matrix.

When Cipher is talking to Agent Smith he makes an important request.  He says, “I wanna be someone important…like an actor.”  This epitomizes the Matrix’s already inherent themes of simulation and relates it to American society.  Cipher wants to be put back into the Matrix.  He wants to be back in the simulated life, he wants to return to his artificial and fake sense of being.  This mimics the artificial life than the uninformed American citizenry compose.  Cipher represents their lack of desire to inform themselves and be contributing members to politics.  He represents the willful choice of ignorance and the “bliss” associated with it.  By asking to be an actor he adds an entire level to the simulation.  An actor in many American eyes is seen as an important person, where in reality all they do is entertain, they do not change the world.  In our society many famous actors are wealthy and famous, despite not being important people.  However, an actor’s job is to simulate.  An actor portrays a fake personality, they assume a role, just like Cipher and just like the American populace.  Cipher’s desire to be an actor displays the importance of simulation in American society.  Many people live created lives, they live a fake life.  Cipher himself is a simulation.

Smoke Signals

Smoke Signals addresses society’s perception of the individual, dilution of culture, and subsequent stereotyping, as well as the reactionary response to such trivialization and pigeonholing. The typical perception of Native Americans differs from person to person, but the prevailing viewpoints are comprised of either spiritual, earth loving, peaceful people or alcoholic, stoic, depressed denizens. The film presents us at its very start with examples of these two stereotypes, the former channeled through Thomas Builds-the-Fire’s grandmother and the latter via Victor Joseph’s father, Arnold. The film counters these stereotypes with Victor Joseph and Thomas Builds-the-Fire themselves, as they are not one dimensional characters, but convey feelings of pride, introspection, and dissatisfaction with the world around them.

Though they may be multifaceted characters, it is stressed that we only know this because the viewer is granted insight into their lives and not simply a mere glance at them. Those they encounter, on the other hand, often cannot see past their long, flowing locks and their grim, determined faces, forsaking them as troubled and inferior. Thomas Builds-the-Fire begins the film as a cheerful, innocent face that acts as a foil to the bleak, hardened Victor Joseph. When the pair encounter a former Olympian who describes not being able to perform in the Olympics due to President Carter’s boycott of the games. Thomas Builds-the-Fire says to her “You gymnasts got a lot in common with us Indians”, which she halfheartedly agrees with, but Victor Joseph insults her by saying that her plight is in no way comparable to the trials and tribulations that his people had endured over the centuries. Moments later, the pair’s seats are taken by two cantankerous old coots who, when asked to move to different seats, respond with indifference and thinly veiled disgust at the small request. The pair then move to a different seat and discuss how they must dress in an abrasive manner, have their hair flow long and braidless as a testament to their Indian heritage, and appear stoic and agitated towards others in order to appear warrior like and aggressive. This mask must be put on to fool those around them into thinking that they are not mere people, but something more, something barbaric. Their culture and existence has been continuously trampled upon and usurped. What land they had was taken and, in a forced act of apology, given back to them in small, controlled areas. This can never be undone. Though Victor Joseph and Thomas Builds-the-Fire may be intelligent, thoughtful, caring beings, these qualities are never seen by those around them, they are only dumb drunks or hippies. This idea of stereotyping pervades American society and hurts all those affected by it because it is a dumbing down and simplifying of a wide array of ideals, cultural traditions, and behaviors into meaningless garbage, into a perverted caricature. It does not require much critical thinking to understand why a culture would respond with vehemence and disgust towards this ignorance; hate the sin and the sinner.

The Matrix

The Matrix is an essential film for American Identities. There are pivotal scenes in it which use several concepts that tie directly in several works from class and the character of Neo (The One) is the most essential in this. Neo finds in an early scene that his life has been an illusion. His whole world is actually computer-generated. The fact that Neo is able to get over his shock so swiftly makes a comment on the concept of reality. One of the concepts we have studied is hyper reality, the belief that there is no such thing as actual reality, just varying versions of it. The fact that Neo is able to accept the Matrix so easily suggest that he may have been aware of hyper reality and never truly accepted reality for what it is. This movie raises question if most people live under this belief; and if anyone truly believes in the world that they live in or if they are aware of the fact that reality is a just a version of something else. Interestingly, when Neo is given the choice between the red and blue pill, he does choose the red pill, the one that will break his sense of falsity. This suggests that people are looking for a sense of reality and to break out of hyper reality. The movie also makes a comment about the idea of American heroes. Neo goes from a lazy hacker to hero of the universe throughout the movie. Although being told the mission is dangerous, Neo chooses this option believing it will lead to heroism. This speaks about American nature and the desire to become something that is considered great. Physicality is emphasized throughout this; Neo doesn’t show much emotion. The way the viewer can tell he is getting more self-esteem is the way his fighting abilities progresses. This makes a comment on American mentality at the time and the way physicality is emphasized. Physical attributes and material objects are emphasized- at the time of the movie, computers were gaining popularity. The very concept of a world based on material objects that a computer could create would not have been possible ten years prior to the film being made. The movie also makes a comment about the way religion is emphasized in America; Neo is called “The One” and becomes a Christ figure in the movie. He is resurrected at the end of the movie. In addition to this, his Matrix name is Anderson, Anderson meaning “son of God.” Neo represents several important American great people throughout the name. In addition to playing the traditional hero- average boy turned into superhero- he takes on the role of a savior. The movie combines hyper reality and great American figures in making a comment on America at the time.

The Matrix — Interrogation Scene

“Have you ever stood and stared at it?  Marveled at its beauty, it’s genius?  Billions of people just living out their lives — oblivious.”  So begins a pivotal scene in The Matrix: when Agent Smith is interrogating Morpheus.  During the course of the scene, many very important ideas our laid out, including views about the human condition in general, humanity’s role in nature, and civilization’s various effects on the psyche of individuals.  American Identity, in particular, can be thought of as a specific agent for many of these ideas, mainly because Americans are responsible for many of the technological advancements on the planet (especially the internet).  This first quote that Agent Smith says to Morpheus highlights the most important point, realized in a variety of ways, which claims that postmodern human consciousness has become generic, stagnant, and “oblivious”.  The people in The Matrix, or rather, continuing from the metaphor, the people in the postmodern hyperreal society of the present day industrialized world (which The Matrix can be seen as representing), are entirely removed from reality.  Humans (and, perhaps, specifically Americans) have forever altered civilization by creating this postmodern situation where their is now a technological “reality”; an abstract digital and simulated existence.
Agent Smith continues with the following:  “…but I believe that as a species, human beings define their reality through misery and suffering.  In the perfect world you dream, your primitive cerebrum kept trying to wake up, which is why the Matrix was redesigned to this: the peek of your civilization.”  Here, the Wachowski’s are ironically showing that we have surrounded ourselves with this digital world, and submerged our psyches in a world where many things are only representative of real things, and where there is a disconnect between our everyday experiences and what would actually constitute reality.  In this ay, our identities are being lost, and our individuality is disseminated into the whole, the “matrix”.  According to this view, human consciousness has changed so drastically that our conceptions of what human “identity” even is anymore.  Agent Smith continues:  “Every mammal on this planet instinctively develops a natural equilibrium which its natural environment, but you humans do not.  You move to an area and you multiply and multiply until every natural resource is consumed.  The only way you can survive is to spread to another area … human beings are a disease.”  Following from this, humans have not only destroyed the idea of identity, but also our place in the environment.  By creating these industrialized and technological systems and frameworks, we are also endangering our notions of civilization, equilibrium, and a “natural order”.
In this scene there are many issues that are being raised by the Wachowski brothers regarding identity in the postmodern world.  Ultimately, it seems they are arguing that the postmodern systems which we are all born into, and which are in the process of taking over the world and forever altering the future, might have a negative effect on humanity’s understanding of reality.  In the future, will be able to discern between the real and the synthetic?  How will we know that the world around us is authentic?  Humans have created and replaced previous societal frameworks with, as Mr. Smith puts it, “…a perfect human world where everyone is happy.”

Imitation of Life

Several scenes in The Imitation of Life comment on American Identities and the way floating signifiers affects them. The floating signifier mainly used in this movie is race; and the way Sarah Jane tries to manipulate it to suit herself. Born to Black mother Annie, Sarah Jane tries to pass for White and live a life free of her heritage. The movie sends a clear message that when one tries to avoid their identity, disaster will clearly follow. From the beginning, Sarah Jane’s turmoil over her identity and desire to pass for white leads to issues with her mother. Sarah Jane and Annie are shown fighting early on in the film. Later, Sarah Jane attempts to date a white boy and when he discovers her dishonesty, she is physically beat. Later, Annie catches her working at a job which requires her to pass. At the end of the film, the ultimate disaster occurs: Annie dies, and it can be said that this was the result of Sarah Jane’s attempts to pass. Sarah Jane’s denial of her identity leads to her facing destruction at all levels. She faces severe physical consequences, after she gets eat by her boyfriend. She faces emotional destruction, as her relationship with her mother gets ruined. Her mother pays the ultimate price, as she dies as a result of it. It is said that Annie died of a broken heart due to Sarah Jane’s refusal to see her. The movie makes a commentary about avoiding one’s true identity. Sarah Jane refuses to do this, and as a result death occurred. Race, especially at the time when racism was still a prominent presence in the nation, caused turmoil for many people trying to pass. The title of the movie, Imitation of Life, even refers to this: Sarah Jane does not seem to be living a life, but rather an imitation of life. She does not actually have an identity, just a costume she has created and wears constantly. Sarah Jane is incredibly similar to the character of Clare Kennedy from Passing. Clare Kennedy also goes through the process of shedding her heritage and deciding to pass in the White World. For Both Sarah Jane and Clare, this leaves them void of emotional aspects of themselves. Clare and Sarah Jane both live imitations of life; they lack true substance. They restrain their pasts and both avoid their families, resulting in repressed negative feelings. Both characters face similar fate. Clare dies at the end of Passing, and Sarah Jane faces the death of her mother. Both authors make the same comment on the idea of Passing. When trying to pass out of one’s identity, they basically become imitations (in Clare’s case, it was theorized that she herself was a “floating signifier” and lacked any true identity) and eventually self-destruct. Both the writer of the film and the author of Passing do not believe it possible to deny an identity.

Smoke Signals

The final scene in Smoke Signals makes a powerful comment about the tying of personal culture in with American identities as a whole. Throughout the film, Victor and Thomas struggle with their Indian identities. As they progress through the journey, neither one wants to lose sight of their Indian identities but they also begin to come forth with their American Identities. The final scene is symbolic of the merging of the two. The final scene features Victor on top of a bridge, scattering his father’s ashes. As he does so, sweeping shots of the water and mountain are displayed. In the background, Thomas recites a poem about fathers. As he does, tribal music begins to pick up as Victor lets out a scream. The movie ends on this. The poem is symbolic of the father-son theme in the movie (the first line in it is “how do we forgive our fathers?” referring to Victor and Thomas’s conflicting feelings about Arnold) but also, of an American theme as a whole. The poem reflects something that is possible nationally for everyone to contribute to and likely, have their own experience with. Father-son issues are not limited to the Indian culture; most people in America have individual problems with this relationship. He talks about families issues and either emotional warmth or coldness. The idea of problems within the family takes the scene with just Victor and opens it up to the nation as a whole, cementing Victor and Thomas’s American identities. Simultaneously, the tribal music begins to play. This represents the merging of their American and Indian identities. While he is talking about a national issue, a piece of culture confined to Native American’s begins to play. Victor and Thomas do not necessarily believe that they can maintain both identities, but the final scene seems to indicate their acceptance that they can. Smoke Signals and Giovanni’s Room feature two of the similar themes. The first is the struggle that occurs when attempting to juggle two cultures. David struggles to choose a culture- his American culture tells him not to enter in his relationship with Giovanni, but his French culture dictates that it is more acceptable. Unlike Thomas and Victor, David is unable to make peace with the merging of two cultures. The second theme featured in both is the struggle between father and sons. Much of David’s fears come from his father, and his expectation that David find a nice girl and come home. Both Victor and David feel stifled by their father’s presence and feel it creating a driving force in their life. Victor drives him to resent his Indian identity due to what he feels is the false heroism of his father; David’s drives him to ruin his relationship with Giovanni. Both of these themes represent American Identities as a whole. Trouble within the family is a nation wide theme in books and films that has always existed. In addition, searching for the self within one’s culture and nation continues to be on going theme.

Planet of the Apes

Planet of the Apes makes an interesting social commentary on American Identities. The final scene is essential in this commentary. In the final scene, Taylor and Nova travel to the Forbidden Zone, where it is revealed that it is actually New York City and he sees the charred remains of The Statue of Liberty. Prior to this, Dr. Zaius had the remains of the human civilization destroyed. Taylor cries out, in disbelief that the apes destroyed this mark of humanity. He refers to them as “maniacs” saying they “finally did it”. Although the comment on the surface may be referring to the apes, the commentary it makes on identities reflects on human’s self-destructive nature. At the time when the film was created, environmental crises and the effect humans had on Earth were beginning to become more prominent. The film shows the severe effects of this; believing that eventually humans could harm the Earth to the degree that it was able to be taken over by Apes. Americans at the time were beginning to behave in ways that would eventually harm them and the film tries to act as a foreshadowing of what could occur if we continue to behave in this manner. It also makes a comment on the lack of ability for Americans to take responsibility for their actions. The characters in Planet of the Apes do not ever consider the planet they are on is Earth despite several clues throughout the movie. This idea is similar to the one presented in the graphic novel Black Hole. Black Hole also focuses on the idea of self-destruction. The characters in this novel are aware that people they are engaging in sexual behaviors with are “sick” with the illness; however they so despite this, for personal gain. Similarly, people at the time when Planet of the Apes was filmed knew acting in a way could eventually lead to permanent damage being done to the Earth, but continued the behavior anyway. Both works make a commentary on acting in careless manners by showing the extremes that could occur. In the case of Planet of the Apes, it is an ape civilization taking control, in the case of Black Hole it is the humans growing mutations. Both works also use mutations. The characters in both are considered grotesque. In Planet of the Apes, it is disturbing to see the parallel view of apes in control and humans as subservient to them. In Black Hole, humans grow appendages that cause social isolation. This is part of the social commentary the authors are trying to make as they are making the point that if the inner self is acting in a greedy or disgusting way, then that is what the outer self will reflect. Both films also make a comment on the idea of paradise gone awry. In the Planet of the Apes, it is more explicit: the apes specifically say New York City was supposed to be paradise. In Black Hole, Charles Burns utilizes the teenage paradise and distorts it. Both use the idea of Americans taking paradise and destroying it through their own behaviors.